Burngreave Green Party activist defends Cllr Mustafa Ahmed

“I will protect my friend’s reputation from being unfairly attacked for being anti-semitic“.

A Jewish Green Party activist from Burngreave has written in defence of his Councillor, Mustafa Ahmed, who has been at the centre of attacks from Labour and other Councillors since the publication of the Jewish Chronicle, attacking him for social media posts from 3 years ago.

Cuthbert Baines holding the Green Party banner at an anti-racism protest.

Cuthbert Baines, co-ward organiser for Burngreave, writes

“This is my personal reflection on the situation from last week. 

As someone who grew up as part of the culturally Jewish global diaspora, I just want to say thank you to those trying to protect me from anti-semitic abuse, but your concern is completely unnecessary.  Mustafa is one of the best people I’ve ever known, and the Jewish Chronicle isn’t a fact-based news publication.  Mustafa has always worked to promote the cause of peace, democracy, freedom and human rights for everyone  (his quote and mine), but the Jewish Chronicle has been proven to be an enemy to the cause of peace, democracy, freedom and human rights.

Are we seriously going to debate the rights and wrongs of an Arabic word that was embedded in a quote of a Facebook post by a famous author (who’s from a country that’s currently being ethnically cleansed by Israel) that our friend and teammate shared on Facebook 3 years ago?

Let’s suppose the Jewish Chronicle are right and using the word “Yahud” in the context of the post he shared is really bad; they have only found one example of him posting the word “yahud” on social media in that context, and that was years ago, so it isn’t part of his usual language.  Mustafa is under the impression that it is referring to people who live in an area of land and not people who belong to an ethnic or religious group, and that’s good enough for me.  After a little bit of digging around, it turns out that the word has Aramaic roots and it was borrowed by the Arabic language centuries later; it also turns out that there is a very similar word that happens to be the name used by the Persian and Neo-Babylonian empires for the province on the bit of land that is currently occupied by Israel ” Yehud”.   This is not even controversial because the Israelis have a town with that name, and they have properties for sale there right now!  Unfortunately, they won’t let Mustafa buy one and move in, but I can guarantee they would roll out the red carpet for me.  (link at the end)

Mustafa has an incredible track record of doing good things and being a good person to everyone he meets; he doesn’t have a track record of being abusive, aggressive or nasty to anyone.  He doesn’t try to find differences and disagreements with people; he tries to find common ground, and he would work with anyone to do good deeds and make the world a better place.

The Jewish Chronicle, on the other hand, has trawled through his social media history actively trying to find something… anything… to be “offended” by; someone should tell the Labour Party that two can play at that game:

Crisis at Jewish Chronicle as stories based on ‘wild fabrications’ are withdrawn (Guardian)

Jewish Chronicle pays out £50,000 and apologises for wrongly linking charity to terror group (Press Gazette)

Jewish Chronicle rapped by IPSO over lack of evidence for claims about Labour activist

How they get to call themselves Jewish and claim to have the moral authority to dictate what is and isn’t offensive to people like me is beyond my understanding.  The Labour councillors have been looking for an excuse to end the cooperation agreement with the Green Party, and they have finally found one.  If they want to die on the hill of one word in one Facebook post shared 3 years ago, they are welcome to campaign for people to vote for them on that basis.  Is this a legit issue?

Does Fran Belbin want me to scroll through her social media history and find all the statements she made supporting that war criminal Keir Starmer to be PM?  He said it was OK to turn the water off for 2 million people providing they are arab palestinians, if it was Israelis in Tel Aviv he would be against it.

I will do whatever I can to protect my friend’s public image and reputation from being unfairly attacked for being anti-semitic even though his Ward team has at least two people with Jewish heritage in it and both of us get on great with Mustafa!

If someone wanted to know if Mustafa is actually an anti-Semitic person, then his culturally Jewish ward organiser should be the first person to be asked about his behaviour and language.  Has Mustafa ever started slagging off all Jews?  No.  Has Mustafa ever repeated the well-known tropes and blood libels that everyone is aware of?  No.  Has Mustafa ever made you feel like you have a responsibility for the crimes being done in your name by the Israeli state and its enablers like the Labour Party?  No, but that’s not how I feel.  I feel like I have a responsibility to speak out because I’ve seen what happens to muslims when they do it, so if I can use my Jewishness to promote the cause of peace, democracy, freedom and human rights, I have a duty to do it.

Unfortunately we live in a world where a Jewish person like me gets treated like I’m a fragile and pathetic individual who can’t be allowed to hear any criticism of anything bad that my own blood relatives may actually be involved in, but Muslim people like Mustafa are free to be attacked without any expectation of consequences and always have to be made to apologise for all the crimes ever committed by any of their fellow members of their religion.

I’ve been thinking and planning for this kind of situation ever since I heard the BS the Labour councillors were spreading about Mustafa during the last election campaign (btw they faced no consequences for it!).  Now the Labour Party is weaponising Jewish heritage to get one of the best people I’ve ever known turned into a social pariah —not on my watch!

#keepitreal

Cuthbert Baines, The Humble Deliveries Coordinator and Co-Ward Organiser of Burngreave Ward.

“Yehud is an ancient city, mentioned since antiquity, which in the twentieth century became a Gush Dan suburb, served by Route 461 and close to Route 4. “

If you go on this website, they are advertising properties for sale!

https://israelstart.com/en/city/yehud

The Province of Judea Under Persia and Greece: 538–168 BC

https://www.historyinthebible.com/supplementary_pages/map-of-yehuda-judea.html

The province of Yehud

https://store.carta-jerusalem.com/carta-map-bank/402-the-province-of-yehud.html

Mustafa’s statement on the allegations.

I completely reject the politically motivated smear campaign led by the Jewish Chronicle and echoed by political opportunists. Following the initial reporting, I was poorly advised to take down the 2023 repost and issue a response; having since taken advice, I am clarifying my position without equivocation. The accusation of antisemitism regarding my repost of Palestinian writer Adham Sharkawi relies on a deliberate distortion of language. In Palestinian political vernacular, Yahud is routinely used to denote the Israeli state and its apparatus rather than Jewish people collectively, a linguistic reality acknowledged by mainstream broadcasters, including the BBC. Stripping an Arabic text of its cultural and political context to manufacture a controversy is a bad-faith tactic aimed at policing language and suppressing anti-colonial speech.

My opposition to Zionism and the policies of the Israeli state is principled, consistent, and grounded entirely in human rights and international law. I am prepared to take the necessary actions against those who continue to attack me. Anti-Zionism is not antisemitism, and conflating the two serves only to shield state violence from legitimate scrutiny. While I stand firmly against all genuine forms of racism. I will not retreat from my solidarity with the Palestinian people’s struggle for justice and self-determination. I correct the record plainly: political dissent against state oppression will not be silenced by manufactured outrage, and I stand firmly behind the right to advocate for Palestinian liberation. I therefore reshare my initial post, which has deliberately been used to target me in a vicious witch hunt against those on the right side of history.

Sheffield Tribune report

https://www.sheffieldtribune.co.uk/fear-lies-and-and-paranoia-how-sheffields-joint-administration-fell-apart (paywall)

My thoughts

I think Mustafa’s social media posts were ill-advised because we know our enemies use any comments that could be either maliciously mistranslated or poorly translated to make us appear anti-semitic. I will leave it to scholars of Arabic to decide, but I will be guided by the Sheffield Green Party statement published in the Star Online, which is as follows.

“The text describes political dissent within the Arab and Muslim world and is a call for faith, conscience and solidarity with Palestine. It is an example of what is typically seen in a lot of texts in the Middle East and North Africa when referencing resistance against Israeli occupation and colonisation, and doesn’t necessarily refer to all Jewish people worldwide. The criticism is aimed entirely at other Arabs and Muslims, framing their political dissent as spiritual/moral betrayal. It seeks to shame an internal group, not to describe an external one.”

The Green Party website just has this comment on it.

I am sure that Mustafa had no intention to be anti-Semitic. I prefer to judge someone by their actions, and it is very difficult to think of any Sheffield Councillor as hard-working and caring for everyone in the community as Mustafa. Those demanding his resignation should turn their wrath on people doing actual harm, such as our Prime Minister Andy Burnham, who continues to sell weapons to the Israeli regime, even though they are currently involved in a genocide, according to the UNHRC Commission of Inquiry on Gaza genocide, the International Association of Genocide Scholars, Oxfam, Human Rights Watch, Genocide Watch and many more very well-respected international organisations.

Labour Leader Fran Belbin has used the Jewish Chronicle article as the final straw to end the cooperative agreement with the Greens, when actually the NEC were threatening her with disciplinary action if she didn’t comply with them and end the agreement.

Meanwhile, Labour continue to ignore the fact that the Council is run by a Committee System. It’s our City recently posted on Facebook

“#Sheffield #sheffieldissuper the ‘soap opera’ like events of recent weeks both inside the Town Hall and outside on social media/in the press are far removed from what we should be able to expect from our Councillors. No party has ‘executive power’ over the others, and no party is in ‘opposition’. All 84 Councillors need to work together for the good of the city.”


Discover more from Tell the Truth Sheffield

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.