One year of climate emergency, but Sheffield Council still haven’t sounded the alarm!

In February 2019, one year ago, I presented the Sheffield Council meeting with a petition, pleading with them to declare a climate emergency. This they did, and later agreed to become carbon neutral by 2030. But what has happened to the urgency of this initial declaration?

Other cities are making progress.  Sheffield, however, has failed to deliver the Citizen’s Assembly that was promised to take place before the end of last year. They have failed to tell the truth to the citizens of Sheffield, making very little effort to inform us about the dangers of climate and ecological breakdown either on their website, in their press releases or in communications to residents. They have failed to act on the Tyndall Report which established a carbon budget for the city. The report recommends that the city must not exceed a budget of 16 million tonnes of carbon emissions before 2038. At current rates of energy consumption, Sheffield will use its entire budget in less than 6 years. 

The Tyndall Report told the Council to “Initiate an immediate programme of CO2 mitigation to deliver cuts in emissions averaging 14% per year to deliver a Paris aligned carbon budget.” There are no signs that any significant reductions have been made in the first year of the emergency, so the percentage of annual cuts must now be increased. 14% cuts will only achieve net-zero by 2038, not 2030 as promised by the Council or 2025 as demanded by Extinction Rebellion.

Other cities are way ahead of Sheffield. Nottingham boasts about a series of schemes to transform the cities 27000 council homes into some of the greenest housing stock in the UK. With external insulation and solar panels, they are creating a massive win-win situation. Lower bills for tenants, less fuel poverty, less CO2 emissions.

Nottingham has also implemented a workplace parking levy. Employers with more than 11 car park spaces must pay the Council per parking space. Money raised from this has improved cycle routes, trams, buses and the railway station. The net effect is less congestion and much improved public transport, so more people choose to leave their car at home. Contrast this with Sheffield, where the Council consulted on a Clean Air Zone in the city centre which doesn’t even include private cars! 

York is going even further. They plan to ban cars inside the city wall within 3 years. Only buses and disabled drivers are exempt from the ban. The council also wants to trial a driver-less electric shuttle service in order to help disabled people get around the city centre. Birmingham is planning a traffic-free city centre too and will be building homes on car park sites. 

Nottingham is planning to get residents to separate their food waste and use this to produce biogas for the city’s buses. School kitchens will be incentivised to source food locally to reduce food miles. There are plans to plant 50,000 trees, in a major contrast to Sheffield that has only recently been forced to stop chopping them down. 

The main reason for Nottingham’s success in reducing harmful emissions seems to be the holistic approach they take, integrating green thinking into all decisions. 

Leeds has an impressive website which educates the public about how they can reduce their carbon footprint and explains in simple terms what the climate emergency is. It could be better, but its streets ahead of what Sheffield has managed.

Bristol City Council was the first local authority to declare a climate emergency. It committed to making the council carbon neutral by 2025 and the whole city by 2030. It has published its action plan, which commits the council to a 200% increase in renewable energy, low-emission public transport, building a waste centre to improve recycling rates, installing solar panels on 10,000 council houses, retrofitting 7,000 homes with insulation and other energy efficiency measures each year, as well as training councillors and staff in climate change issues.

Many cities have initiated Citizen’s Assemblies, where members of the public, chosen in a similar way to jury service, are presented with the facts about the climate emergency and then asked to make recommendations for the Council to implement. Brighton and Oxford have done this successfully and Leeds have carried out a Citizens Jury. 

One thing Sheffield has done since declaring a climate emergency is to change to a renewable energy provider. Good, but green energy has been available now for more than 20 years. My household converted back in 1999.  Why has the Council taken so long to get around to this? I’m afraid they get no brownie points from me for this very belated action. 

With the recent flooding in South Yorkshire, unprecedented bush fires in Australia, California and the Artic and catastrophic flooding in Indonesia it has never been clearer that we must act now to save ourselves from climate chaos. Sheffield’s Labour Councillors must step up to the challenge and stop fiddling while the planet burns.



Tyndall Report

Sheffield Green City Strategy 2016


Nottingham Workplace Parking Levy


Leeds website





Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: